WHO Poll
Q:



the coming of gary 5:00 Wed Nov 9
all - time England / Scotland combined XI
... from today's Daily Telegraph ;

Banks

Neville
Moore
Hansen
McGrain

Gascoigne
Souness
Robson
Charlton

Law
Dalglish
.

Replies - Newest Posts First (Show In Chronological Order)

Telford Iron 2:20 Thu Nov 10
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
Banks

McGrain
Pearce
Moore
Hughes

Souness
Robson
Charlton
Gazza

Dalglish
Keegan

Grumpster 10:57 Thu Nov 10
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
In my lifetime of being a proper football fan (guess about 85 onwards), maybe only Dalgleish and Hansen would have a sniff of getting into a joint team.

They've been fucking gash for as long as I've known.

Kelly Smunt 10:51 Thu Nov 10
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
Parkes
Stewart Martin Moore Lampard snr
Devonshire Peters Brooking Hutchison
McAvennie Hurst

jack flash 10:27 Thu Nov 10
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
Can't be bothered to write it out in full but:-

The England 1966 WC Final team only substitute Dave Mackay for Alan Ball & Kenny Dalglish for Roger Hunt

Far Cough 8:42 Thu Nov 10
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
Baxter is a good shout but may be a luxury player

Worst Case Ontario 3:57 Thu Nov 10
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
Shilton

Hughes Moore McNeill McGrain

Baxter Charlton Scholes Matthews

Dalglish Greaves

, 12:44 Thu Nov 10
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
Might be an easier exercise to choose best ever England and best Scotland elevens and then pick a best combined eleven.

To me the Scots had some great players in the past that have not been mentioned. Apart from Dave MacKay don't forget that Jim Baxter and Billy Bremner were great players and so too was Jimmy Johnson. England too would have to consider the relative merits of Greaves, Hurst, Keegan, Linekar and Peters for starters.

neilalex 12:15 Thu Nov 10
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
Dave Mackay would have eaten Souness and Robson for breakfast.

http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/news/jimmy-greaves-dave-mackay-tottenhams-5261980

theaxeman 11:08 Wed Nov 9
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
Banks

McGrain... Ferdinand... Moore... Sanson

Jinky Johnson...Charlton...Robson...Robertson

..................Dalgleish

...................................Greaves

Far Cough 7:01 Wed Nov 9
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
Mart, I left him out because you need Law for his aerial presence

Mart O 6:46 Wed Nov 9
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
Far Cough 6:41 Wed Nov 9

On the contrary, imagine him behind Greavsie, doing what he did for Ian Rush.

Far Cough 6:41 Wed Nov 9
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
Tough to leave Dalglish out but he has to make way for England's best ever forward in Greaves

Eerie Descent 6:40 Wed Nov 9
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
I suppose you'd have a team full of Jocks, you England hating cuntbag?

Mart O 6:38 Wed Nov 9
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
Northern Sold 6:16 Wed Nov 9

One of the best I've seen. Phenomenal. Really.

Northern Sold 6:16 Wed Nov 9
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
Always Dalglish for me... magnificent player

Far Cough 5:37 Wed Nov 9
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
Greaves instead of Dalglish, that will still leave you with the King Denis Law in the air

i-Ron 5:32 Wed Nov 9
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
Yeah I suppose I am.

Takashi Miike 5:32 Wed Nov 9
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
*Johnstone*

Takashi Miike 5:32 Wed Nov 9
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
*Johnstone*

One McAvennieeeeee 5:31 Wed Nov 9
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
YOU COMING AT ME, EYE WRONNE?

Takashi Miike 5:31 Wed Nov 9
Re: all - time England / Scotland combined XI
Banks
Mcgrain - Hansen - Moore - Pearce
Johnston - Brooking - Charlton - Baxter
Dalglish - Greaves

Page 1 - Next




Copyright 2006 WHO.NET | Powered by: