WHO Poll
Q:



gph 8:19 Thu Sep 28
Video ref
Just heard a report on Radio 4 saying they could be in place by the time of the FA Cup Third Round, after successful trials of a system somewhere or other (look, I was driving, so not fully concentrating on radio, and I can't find the online version to fill in the gaps).

Would've been nice if they'd been around to catch the shirt-tug on Arnautovic

Replies - Newest Posts First (Show In Chronological Order)

kylay 6:33 Fri Sep 29
Re: Video ref
VAR in the MLS is an abortion, and they still cannot get calls correct even with the replay. Under MLS rules they claim you can only review goals, red cards, mistaken identity, and penalty kicks. The catch is you can review whether any foul (seen or not) should have been a red card, so effectively any time players come together. for goals and penalties, you can review the attacking phase of play (undefined) to go back and call a foul that should have been given to negate the goal. Effectively everything is reviewable.

Check out the 4 minute mark of this video to see VAR in all of it's glory:

https://matchcenter.mlssoccer.com/matchcenter/2017-09-20-atlanta-united-fc-vs-la-galaxy/details/video/135075

In that game there were a total of 3 reviews. The 2 in the first half added 5 minutes of injury time to that half.

El Scorchio 11:54 Fri Sep 29
Re: Video ref
Far Cough 9:35

That's madness. So trying to point out something the ref has missed results in the player getting a yellow? Crazy.

Also we know it won't apply to anyone wearing a Man U or Chelsea shirt as per most of the other existing similar rules.

Razzle 11:33 Fri Sep 29
Re: Video ref
Its all here...

http://www.theifab.com/projects/video-assistant-referees-vars-experiment?tab=1

VAR is still in the experiment phase and the UK leagues are not part of the experiment.

Kelly Smunt 11:11 Fri Sep 29
Re: Video ref
Yes gph, but it's Tottenham, it still wouldn't have been given.

Bouncing Ludo 11:04 Fri Sep 29
Re: Video ref
This is how it works in MLS

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/41430247

Far Cough 9:35 Thu Sep 28
Re: Video ref
I might be wrong but the ref can only call for a review on something he saw but is not sure about, the Arnie tug wouldn't apply under that scenario as I don't think players or coaches can call for a review, in fact under the rules I saw, making a gesture for a review by a player is to be a yellow card offence





Copyright 2006 WHO.NET | Powered by: