Amazon Search and Bookmark
AFFILIATE SEARCH | Shop Amazon.co.uk using this search bar and support WHO!

Overrated players

West Ham Online's Football Forum
Post Reply
Nutsin
Posts: 3722
Old WHO Number: 274983
Has liked: 270 times
Been liked: 449 times

Overrated players

Post Nutsin »

Fuck me that Havertz is way overrated, So is Foden but Havertz is worse.

as for overrated Hammers I’d have to say Lucas Neil takes it just from Ravel Morrison.

Who stands out to you?
Council Scum
Posts: 799
Old WHO Number: 19891
Has liked: 2 times
Been liked: 301 times

Re: Overrated players

Post Council Scum »

El Scorchio" wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 11:09 I don't like John Terry and he's done a fucking tonne of twattish things, but he was a very very good defender.

You're not the mainstay and captain of that moneybags Chelsea era if you're not. They could have got anyone in to replace him if they wanted, and they didn't.
The better defenders were alongside him Caravlho, Desailly, Gallas, having Makelele sat in front of him. Essien etc.

Terry was your typical English defender, all blood, guts and last ditch defending, but he got skinned for fun on numerous occasions and was helped by all of the above and with being English in a team that needed its quoter. 
User avatar
El Scorchio
Posts: 4618
Old WHO Number: 227648
Has liked: 283 times
Been liked: 1379 times

Re: Overrated players

Post El Scorchio »

I don't like John Terry and he's done a fucking tonne of twattish things, but he was a very very good defender.

You're not the mainstay and captain of that moneybags Chelsea era if you're not. They could have got anyone in to replace him if they wanted, and they didn't.
Council Scum
Posts: 799
Old WHO Number: 19891
Has liked: 2 times
Been liked: 301 times

Re: Overrated players

Post Council Scum »

RBshorty wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 10:41 Fair point CS. John Terry has to here. Stole a living running along side a few world class defenders.?
Had Jonathan Woodgate not been so injury prone I doubt he would have got many caps. Even Ledley King was a better defender. 
violator
Posts: 936
Old WHO Number: 15360
Has liked: 326 times
Been liked: 318 times

Re: Overrated players

Post violator »

Don't John Terry hold the record goals scored in the Prem by a defender...40 odd goals
RBshorty
Posts: 1181
Old WHO Number: 211268
Has liked: 140 times
Been liked: 174 times

Re: Overrated players

Post RBshorty »

Fair point CS. John Terry has to here. Stole a living running along side a few world class defenders.?
User avatar
Massive Attack
Posts: 8660
Old WHO Number: 321955
Has liked: 5038 times
Been liked: 2702 times

Re: Overrated players

Post Massive Attack »

Rossal wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 10:25
Massive Attack" wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 09:45
Rossal wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 09:34
its all a myth. He was stuck on LW cos he wasn't good enough to play through the middle.  Doesn't matter what he is doing now, this is about his time with us. 

And the regular European campaigns going deep in to Tournaments for any Team? 
For us and Betis according to wiki he has played over 50 games.  Scored 3 goals, all in the conference league with us. 

Like I said, that wasn't his only game. His Team ethic and passing game is more important. 1 Trophy, 2 Finals, 1 Semi Final and another Quarters with him regularly playing says he must be doijg something right for 2 unfashionable different Teams from different Countries.
Council Scum
Posts: 799
Old WHO Number: 19891
Has liked: 2 times
Been liked: 301 times

Re: Overrated players

Post Council Scum »

RBshorty wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 10:33 Robbie Savage has to in the conversation.
Who rated him then? 
RBshorty
Posts: 1181
Old WHO Number: 211268
Has liked: 140 times
Been liked: 174 times

Re: Overrated players

Post RBshorty »

Robbie Savage has to in the conversation.
Rossal
Posts: 1019
Old WHO Number: 270755
Has liked: 25 times
Been liked: 153 times

Re: Overrated players

Post Rossal »

Massive Attack" wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 09:45
Rossal wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 09:34
Massive Attack" wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 09:18

The ultimate Team player who's game wasn't just about goals but also making the Team tick with his passes as well as getting stuck in when he aint stuck out on the left wing. No surprise to see him now get 7 goals, 6 assists, 5th in La Liga and going well in Europe again in yet another Quarter Final. Cannot be a coincidence the amount of times he goes deep in to European Competitions when he plays.
its all a myth. He was stuck on LW cos he wasn't good enough to play through the middle.  Doesn't matter what he is doing now, this is about his time with us. 

And the regular European campaigns going deep in to Tournaments for any Team? 
For us and Betis according to wiki he has played over 50 games.  Scored 3 goals, all in the conference league with us. 
zico
Posts: 5047
Old WHO Number: 10629
Has liked: 672 times
Been liked: 455 times

Re: Overrated players

Post zico »

Pogba for me. One good game in ten at United maybe. Didn't see him much at Juventus so might be being harsh but never saw what the fuss was about.
Vexed
Posts: 1364
Old WHO Number: 240179
Has liked: 4 times
Been liked: 445 times

Re: Overrated players

Post Vexed »

Fauxstralian wrote: 22 Mar 2026, 22:30 Saka
Didnt see the game today but presume he shat the bed again when it matters
But he always looks so pleased when he's launched one into row K, that's what annoys me most. Shaun Wright-Fucking-Phillips style chumpery. 
User avatar
Massive Attack
Posts: 8660
Old WHO Number: 321955
Has liked: 5038 times
Been liked: 2702 times

Re: Overrated players

Post Massive Attack »

Vieira
User avatar
Far Cough UKunt
Posts: 2381
Has liked: 655 times
Been liked: 1030 times

Re: Overrated players

Post Far Cough UKunt »

Who is the most overrated spitter? El Hadji Diouf, Frank Rijkaard or Jamie Carragher?
Chinkey Weasel
Posts: 49
Has liked: 87 times
Been liked: 22 times

Re: Overrated players

Post Chinkey Weasel »

El Hadji Diouf *spits*
Council Scum
Posts: 799
Old WHO Number: 19891
Has liked: 2 times
Been liked: 301 times

Re: Overrated players

Post Council Scum »

Far Cough UKunt" wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 09:38 Giggs? but but but but he scored that wonderful goal when he tore his shirt off and everyone saw his hairy Welsh chest. 
And he got lucky with that goal, couple of times he should have lost the ball and it went right for him. 
User avatar
fraser
Posts: 3426
Old WHO Number: 10134
Has liked: 294 times
Been liked: 709 times

Re: Overrated players

Post fraser »

Massive Attack" wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 09:45
Rossal wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 09:34
Massive Attack" wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 09:18

The ultimate Team player who's game wasn't just about goals but also making the Team tick with his passes as well as getting stuck in when he aint stuck out on the left wing. No surprise to see him now get 7 goals, 6 assists, 5th in La Liga and going well in Europe again in yet another Quarter Final. Cannot be a coincidence the amount of times he goes deep in to European Competitions when he plays.
its all a myth. He was stuck on LW cos he wasn't good enough to play through the middle.  Doesn't matter what he is doing now, this is about his time with us. 

And the regular European campaigns going deep in to Tournaments for any Team? 
This may go on for quite a while... 
User avatar
Massive Attack
Posts: 8660
Old WHO Number: 321955
Has liked: 5038 times
Been liked: 2702 times

Re: Overrated players

Post Massive Attack »

Rossal wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 09:34
Massive Attack" wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 09:18
Rossal wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 09:12 Fornals 

bang average for us yet people hark on like he was tonnes of goals and assists we let go 

The ultimate Team player who's game wasn't just about goals but also making the Team tick with his passes as well as getting stuck in when he aint stuck out on the left wing. No surprise to see him now get 7 goals, 6 assists, 5th in La Liga and going well in Europe again in yet another Quarter Final. Cannot be a coincidence the amount of times he goes deep in to European Competitions when he plays.
its all a myth. He was stuck on LW cos he wasn't good enough to play through the middle.  Doesn't matter what he is doing now, this is about his time with us. 

And the regular European campaigns going deep in to Tournaments for any Team? 
User avatar
Far Cough UKunt
Posts: 2381
Has liked: 655 times
Been liked: 1030 times

Re: Overrated players

Post Far Cough UKunt »

Giggs? but but but but he scored that wonderful goal when he tore his shirt off and everyone saw his hairy Welsh chest. 
Rossal
Posts: 1019
Old WHO Number: 270755
Has liked: 25 times
Been liked: 153 times

Re: Overrated players

Post Rossal »

Massive Attack" wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 09:18
Rossal wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 09:12 Fornals 

bang average for us yet people hark on like he was tonnes of goals and assists we let go 

The ultimate Team player who's game wasn't just about goals but also making the Team tick with his passes as well as getting stuck in when he aint stuck out on the left wing. No surprise to see him now get 7 goals, 6 assists, 5th in La Liga and going well in Europe again in yet another Quarter Final. Cannot be a coincidence the amount of times he goes deep in to European Competitions when he plays.
its all a myth. He was stuck on LW cos he wasn't good enough to play through the middle.  Doesn't matter what he is doing now, this is about his time with us. 
Pub Bigot
Posts: 957
Old WHO Number: 255703
Has liked: 1249 times
Been liked: 473 times

Re: Overrated players

Post Pub Bigot »

Matty Upson. Prick. 
Eerie Decent
Posts: 1441
Has liked: 257 times
Been liked: 689 times

Re: Overrated players

Post Eerie Decent »

Wan-Bissaka
User avatar
Massive Attack
Posts: 8660
Old WHO Number: 321955
Has liked: 5038 times
Been liked: 2702 times

Re: Overrated players

Post Massive Attack »

Rossal wrote: 25 Mar 2026, 09:12 Fornals 

bang average for us yet people hark on like he was tonnes of goals and assists we let go 

The ultimate Team player who's game wasn't just about goals but also making the Team tick with his passes as well as getting stuck in when he aint stuck out on the left wing. No surprise to see him now get 7 goals, 6 assists, 5th in La Liga and going well in Europe again in yet another Quarter Final. Cannot be a coincidence the amount of times he goes deep in to European Competitions when he plays.
Rossal
Posts: 1019
Old WHO Number: 270755
Has liked: 25 times
Been liked: 153 times

Re: Overrated players

Post Rossal »

Fornals 

bang average for us yet people hark on like he was tonnes of goals and assists we let go 
violator
Posts: 936
Old WHO Number: 15360
Has liked: 326 times
Been liked: 318 times

Re: Overrated players

Post violator »

Neymar
Council Scum
Posts: 799
Old WHO Number: 19891
Has liked: 2 times
Been liked: 301 times

Re: Overrated players

Post Council Scum »

Giggs. Don't get me wrong, he was a great player, but not the player Sky would have you believe. 

But then the same could be said about Beckham. 
Post Reply