AFFILIATE SEARCH | Shop Amazon.co.uk using this search bar and support WHO!
Modern football fans.
Modern football fans.
Two stories. Both in the Telegraph. Modern football is a bit shit isn't it?
This is the thing about our stadium. Its not great as we all know. But these two stadiums, one regarded as the best modern football stadium in the world and the other an old skool stadium, yet they are both having the same problems we are having.
It's modern fans. Not the stadiums.
This is the thing about our stadium. Its not great as we all know. But these two stadiums, one regarded as the best modern football stadium in the world and the other an old skool stadium, yet they are both having the same problems we are having.
It's modern fans. Not the stadiums.
-
Dick Shaftsbury
- Posts: 322
- Old WHO Number: 319145
- Has liked: 321 times
- Been liked: 183 times
Re: Modern football fans.
When you watch old footage like this of the 1980 quarter final:
It's all young lads. Of course the atmosphere was raucous.
Now its kids, women, families, the whole demographic.
It's all young lads. Of course the atmosphere was raucous.
Now its kids, women, families, the whole demographic.
- Far Cough UKunt
- Posts: 2120
- Has liked: 560 times
- Been liked: 895 times
- Mad Ferret
- Posts: 2317
- Has liked: 210 times
- Been liked: 364 times
Re: Modern football fans.
I’d say it’s both.
VAR has affected the atmosphere more than many people realise. Feels like you can’t celebrate a goal anymore.
I noticed when Wilson scored the last minute winner on Sat, usually the away end would be in raptures, but it seemed not to be the case. I think many people were expecting the goal to be chalked off and didn’t celebrate so wildly.
VAR has affected the atmosphere more than many people realise. Feels like you can’t celebrate a goal anymore.
I noticed when Wilson scored the last minute winner on Sat, usually the away end would be in raptures, but it seemed not to be the case. I think many people were expecting the goal to be chalked off and didn’t celebrate so wildly.
- Far Cough UKunt
- Posts: 2120
- Has liked: 560 times
- Been liked: 895 times
Re: Modern football fans.
I like Sunderland's fans they do a great version of Can't Help Falling in Love.
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 7763
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 4516 times
- Been liked: 2391 times
- Mad Ferret
- Posts: 2317
- Has liked: 210 times
- Been liked: 364 times
- Massive Attack
- Posts: 7763
- Old WHO Number: 321955
- Has liked: 4516 times
- Been liked: 2391 times
Re: Modern football fans.
Mad Ferret" wrote: ↑22 Jan 2026, 08:39
I remember our penultimate game ever there, home to Swansea. The atmosphere honestly was as bad as anything at the London Stadium.
Was it bollocks.
- Mad Ferret
- Posts: 2317
- Has liked: 210 times
- Been liked: 364 times
Re: Modern football fans.
Society changed.
Our fanbase changed. More from the home counties, too many limp-wristed Essex types.
The stadium going all seater.
There were obviously exceptions where the atmosphere was good, but week-to-week it was average at best over there in the end.
I remember our penultimate game ever there, home to Swansea. The atmosphere honestly was as bad as anything at the London Stadium.
Our fanbase changed. More from the home counties, too many limp-wristed Essex types.
The stadium going all seater.
There were obviously exceptions where the atmosphere was good, but week-to-week it was average at best over there in the end.
I remember our penultimate game ever there, home to Swansea. The atmosphere honestly was as bad as anything at the London Stadium.
- Mike Oxsaw
- Posts: 5293
- Location: Flip between Belvedere & Buri Ram and anywhere else I fancy, just because I can.
- Old WHO Number: 14021
- Has liked: 71 times
- Been liked: 723 times
Re: Modern football fans.
Mad Ferret" wrote: ↑22 Jan 2026, 08:05 It does make me laugh when I hear WHU fans bleat on about the Boleyn, or how all our issues would be resolved with a proper football ground.
The atmosphere was shit at the Boleyn in the end, and the atmosphere at any new stadium would be just as shit. Look at the Emirates and the new WHL - both libraries.
UK society is different now and that is reflected in atmospheres inside football grounds.
in your own words, explain why "The atmosphere was shit at the Boleyn in the end".
Provide valid & verifiable examples of what triggered the change(s).
Use crayons if needed.
Provide valid & verifiable examples of what triggered the change(s).
Use crayons if needed.
- Mad Ferret
- Posts: 2317
- Has liked: 210 times
- Been liked: 364 times
Re: Modern football fans.
It does make me laugh when I hear WHU fans bleat on about the Boleyn, or how all our issues would be resolved with a proper football ground.
The atmosphere was shit at the Boleyn in the end, and the atmosphere at any new stadium would be just as shit. Look at the Emirates and the new WHL - both libraries.
UK society is different now and that is reflected in atmospheres inside football grounds.
The atmosphere was shit at the Boleyn in the end, and the atmosphere at any new stadium would be just as shit. Look at the Emirates and the new WHL - both libraries.
UK society is different now and that is reflected in atmospheres inside football grounds.
-
Monsieur merde de cheval
- Posts: 2198
- Has liked: 1380 times
- Been liked: 723 times
- Mike Oxsaw
- Posts: 5293
- Location: Flip between Belvedere & Buri Ram and anywhere else I fancy, just because I can.
- Old WHO Number: 14021
- Has liked: 71 times
- Been liked: 723 times
Re: Modern football fans.
Whilst not detracting from these views, I think that one important element is missing. OUR expectations.
Health warning! This is waffle. If you're easily offended, exit the post now(!) and find something more agreeable.
That's not a criticism of us (as fans) but simply that as we (all) get older (and hopefully wiser). our needs and expectations change - mine...my Road to Jericho, if you like... happened not long after we beat Arsenal in the FA Cup Final; I basically had to make a choice between my career - my (not your) future - and my then current lifestyle. I chose my future.
That meant my expectations from the game as a whole dropped - something I never expected to happen when I eventually got a seat in the stand above the Chicken Run, in line with the North Bank penalty box only 2-3 seasons earlier. My younger, Manchester United supporting - brother was in that seat more than me and I finally relinquished it when he, too, changed his priorities.
I suspect that I was not alone in having that choice to make. Then along came relationships, family and homes to build, all deemed more worthy of my time and money; money was never really the issue though - it was time. Even I couldn't be in two places at the same time.
Rinse & repeat down the years and football becomes the insignificance - to me- that it now is.
My love for the West Ham I grew up with though,holds a very special place in my heart that nobody, absolutely nobody, can occupy or even bid for occupancy. THAT West Ham, though, long ceased to exist and the reasons why probably extent way beyond what I've suggested above.
It certainly didn't help when the bean-counters & parasites took over in the game and tried to monetise that love for their own personal gain; THAT moment I certainly recognise as a point of no return, but, for me, I'd probably reached that point much earlier in my life.
But, what of the future? If "big" clubs cannot attract the fans they expected to keep filling their stadiums, creating the atmosphere that made attending the game such a memorable experience, where will the game go?
Sadly, I think, far, far away from it's birthplace as those now controlling the game switch their focus onto areas of potential financial growth - namely the Middle East & North America.
100 - or even just 50 - years from now, the game (in Europe, at least) will be unrecognisable from what it is today, and certainly what it was in the pre-PL era.
Names we (or even just the media) currently recognise as "big" clubs will just be footnotes in (the game's) history, alongside such greats as The Royal Engineers AFC, Sheffield FC, Wanderers FC, Hallam FC & Barnes FC.
Selfishly, I'm glad I was young enough to enjoy the game as it was in my youth/early days and get far more pleasure from watching the (free) historical clips of games on the internet than I do from watching any current or recent games - even when we win.
Health warning! This is waffle. If you're easily offended, exit the post now(!) and find something more agreeable.
That's not a criticism of us (as fans) but simply that as we (all) get older (and hopefully wiser). our needs and expectations change - mine...my Road to Jericho, if you like... happened not long after we beat Arsenal in the FA Cup Final; I basically had to make a choice between my career - my (not your) future - and my then current lifestyle. I chose my future.
That meant my expectations from the game as a whole dropped - something I never expected to happen when I eventually got a seat in the stand above the Chicken Run, in line with the North Bank penalty box only 2-3 seasons earlier. My younger, Manchester United supporting - brother was in that seat more than me and I finally relinquished it when he, too, changed his priorities.
I suspect that I was not alone in having that choice to make. Then along came relationships, family and homes to build, all deemed more worthy of my time and money; money was never really the issue though - it was time. Even I couldn't be in two places at the same time.
Rinse & repeat down the years and football becomes the insignificance - to me- that it now is.
My love for the West Ham I grew up with though,holds a very special place in my heart that nobody, absolutely nobody, can occupy or even bid for occupancy. THAT West Ham, though, long ceased to exist and the reasons why probably extent way beyond what I've suggested above.
It certainly didn't help when the bean-counters & parasites took over in the game and tried to monetise that love for their own personal gain; THAT moment I certainly recognise as a point of no return, but, for me, I'd probably reached that point much earlier in my life.
But, what of the future? If "big" clubs cannot attract the fans they expected to keep filling their stadiums, creating the atmosphere that made attending the game such a memorable experience, where will the game go?
Sadly, I think, far, far away from it's birthplace as those now controlling the game switch their focus onto areas of potential financial growth - namely the Middle East & North America.
100 - or even just 50 - years from now, the game (in Europe, at least) will be unrecognisable from what it is today, and certainly what it was in the pre-PL era.
Names we (or even just the media) currently recognise as "big" clubs will just be footnotes in (the game's) history, alongside such greats as The Royal Engineers AFC, Sheffield FC, Wanderers FC, Hallam FC & Barnes FC.
Selfishly, I'm glad I was young enough to enjoy the game as it was in my youth/early days and get far more pleasure from watching the (free) historical clips of games on the internet than I do from watching any current or recent games - even when we win.
-
eusebiovic
- Posts: 671
- Old WHO Number: 15391
- Has liked: 1185 times
- Been liked: 233 times
Re: Modern football fans.
DeMOCKracy
There is no escape
The big pricks are out
They'll fuck everything in sight
Watch your back
Harold Pinter - 2003
There is no escape
The big pricks are out
They'll fuck everything in sight
Watch your back
Harold Pinter - 2003
-
John Drake
- Posts: 174
- Has liked: 5 times
- Been liked: 96 times
Re: Modern football fans.
Or it's the product not the fans.
It is expensive to go to games and no longer affordable as afternoon out with your mates or kids. Most matches are boring to watch and bogged down in tactics. VAR has killed the spontaneity. Football is now optimised for media. They love VAR as it provides their talking points and gives them inside information that fans in the stadium don't get to see and hear. It's all about hype and marketing now.
It is expensive to go to games and no longer affordable as afternoon out with your mates or kids. Most matches are boring to watch and bogged down in tactics. VAR has killed the spontaneity. Football is now optimised for media. They love VAR as it provides their talking points and gives them inside information that fans in the stadium don't get to see and hear. It's all about hype and marketing now.
Re: Modern football fans.
Ive felt this for a while. Its not the stadium or the board etc. Most people are fucking annoying and the era of watching football in a stadium as we experienced has ended.
The nail in the coffin, i think, was covid. Our best season in recent memory, no one was there.
People got used to watching at home, and didnt go back. Or they accepted being herded around like idiots and sitting quietly.
Its not just football, any sort of major public event is the same - Pubs are not what they were. Its a shift in society - not just football supporters.
The nail in the coffin, i think, was covid. Our best season in recent memory, no one was there.
People got used to watching at home, and didnt go back. Or they accepted being herded around like idiots and sitting quietly.
Its not just football, any sort of major public event is the same - Pubs are not what they were. Its a shift in society - not just football supporters.

